Science & Engineering

Could an Ornithopter Fly? Biomimicry, Flapping Wings and the Machines of Arrakis

Flapping-wing aircraft already exist. Scaling them up is the real trouble.

Editorial placeholder image for the flapping-wing flight analysis of the Dune ornithopter

In Dune, ornithopters are the standard aircraft of Arrakis: machines that fly by beating wings. It sounds like a fantasy, but it is also a real branch of aerospace engineering with a long history. The interesting question is not whether a flapping machine can fly, but how large one can get.

They already exist

Leonardo da Vinci sketched flapping-wing machines in the late fifteenth century. Modern engineers have actually built them. In 2010, the University of Toronto’s Snowbird, a human-powered ornithopter, flew for 19.3 seconds over 145 metres, an average of around 7.5 m/s. Its wingspan was comparable to that of a small airliner, which tells you how much wing it took to lift one person.

Flapping-wing machines, real and drawn
MachineWhat it showsNote
Leonardo’s designs (late 15th century)The idea is oldConcept sketches; never flew
Snowbird (2010)Human-powered flapping flight is possible19.3 s, 145 m; very large, very light
DelFly (TU Delft)Small flapping drones can carry camerasInsect-scale flapping-wing micro air vehicles
BionicOpter (Festo, 2013)Dragonfly-style control of each wingA laboratory demonstrator

Why scale is the enemy

Lift depends on wing area, which grows with the square of a machine’s size, while weight grows with the cube. So bigger aircraft must work harder to stay aloft. Flapping adds a second problem: each stroke requires the wing to speed up, stop and reverse, which puts repeated stress on the structure and wastes energy. Fixed wings and rotors avoid those reversals, which is why almost every large aircraft uses them.

Placeholder image: an ink-and-paper diagram of a four-winged flying machine in a desert sky
Placeholder diagram of flapping-wing flight.

The desert makes it harder

  • Hot air is thinner. Air density falls as temperature rises, so wings must be larger or faster to generate the same lift.
  • Dust and sand are brutal for bearings, joints and thin wing membranes.
  • Heat affects batteries, motors and structural materials alike.

A dragonfly beats a bird

The recent films’ dragonfly-like wings are arguably more credible than bird-like ones. Dragonflies control four wings independently, which gives them extraordinary manoeuvrability, and the same independent-wing approach has been demonstrated in laboratory robots. It remains much harder to scale to a vehicle carrying people through a sandstorm.

Our verdict: ornithopters can fly, and small ones do so today. The Arrakis version is a triumph of imagination, but the physics prefers rotors and fixed wings as soon as the vehicle becomes large.

Share
Air mail • Par avion

The Nerdvana Dispatch

Stay curious. Stay in the universe.

Get the best of Nerdvana, delivered to your inbox. Theories, stories, fictional technologies, and everything worth exploring.

No spam. No repetitive gibberish. Only pure speculation.

What are you curious about? (optional)